A
You're a wonderful man to take on the responsibility of three boys and you deserve to be happily married to a woman that is caring and compassionate toward all of you. You and your children have already gone through more heartache than anyone should ever endure. So I can understand why you need some peace and happiness. The Lord will help you so be strong and give him time to work. You didn't say whether or not you are a born again Christian. God is so loving and caring about each one of us. He wants us to be happy and content in life with all the blessings and promises that the Bible offers.
Most people take it upon themselves to choose a marriage partner instead of asking God. Since they have no way of seeing what's in the future they are taking a chance, in other words they're gambling with their own future and the future of their children. It's a haphazard , risky way to make such an important decision in life. If you're lucky and work hard this marriage might work. In that statement I chose to use words that are attached to the worldly way of finding a mate. Worldly ways of living and doing come from a sinful nature that was created when Adam and Eve sinned. That nature never provides security or happiness on a permanent basis. You really don't need any of those words attached to your next marriage even if you feel you're deeply in love. Human love can turn sour but godly love will last a lifetime.
There is a reason why none of those words are ever attached to anything God provides. When God accepted the blood of his Son, Jesus, as payment for our sins he offered a covenant relationship to anyone that would repent and accept Jesus as lord over their life. That covenant is binding; God never goes back on his word. Numbers 23:19 God is not a man, that he should lie, nor a son of man, that he should change his mind. God loves all people but only those that choose to be in covenant with God have a right to all the wonderful promises in his Word. Those promises have words attached to them like sure, reward, receive, prosperous, everlasting, whatever you ask etc. These are words of security and increase. I believe this is the kind of marriage you want now or you wouldn't have written.
I don't know what happened in your first marriage but your second choice for a wife was not too successful. I would like to see you turn this area of your life over to God so you will have peace and joy in your home for the rest of your natural days. God knows everything about every body. He knows the future as well as the past for each person who will turn to him, and best of all he forgets our sins. He knows what personality fits best with you as well as with the boys. His choices are always better than ours; they're satisfying deep into our soul, they're secure, sound and permanent. Jeremiah 29:11 For I know the plans I have for you," declares the Lord, "plans to prosper you and not to harm you. If this woman is right for a lifetime of happiness as your marriage partner then it will be proven when you follow the tests and steps I have written for you.
If you are born again then we are ready to talk about your new lady; if not please go to our Salvation Prayer page and give your heart to God so he can begin to move for you.
It is understandable that your youngest son would take the divorce so hard. His world has been torn apart and accepting any woman other than his mother into your lives is going to be hard for him. I know that you need a good wife and a mother for your boys but your children have to be your first priority right now because of the stability they need in their lives. The more you talk to your children and reassure them of your love and dedication the stronger they will become. Doing new activities with them many times will help a child to heal quicker. If your new lady will participate it will also help them adjust to her. Most children need a reason for liking an adult or letting them into their small world.
How often do you plan activities with your new lady that the boys are included? They may just feel left out or that your affection for them is not as strong as it was. Maybe they feel she doesn't like them so they don't want to make an effort to please her. Does your lady ever suggest including the boys in what you do or even a short trip for ice-cream before a date? What kind of feelings does she express when you're all together? How affectionate is she with your boys? Can she carry on a conversation with them or does she talk at them? Is she eager to help them if they have a need? Is her response to them genuine or is it stressed? Does she mind being alone with them for short periods of time? Can you completely trust her with your boys?
If you're discussing marriage then you've been dating long enough that she should be adjusted to each of your boy's by now. Their needs should be important to her especially if she's going to be a nurturing mother to them. Observe her deeply to know her feelings and emotions as to being a nurturing type person. A true mother is a giving person; she gives her time, effort, love and compassion. She is willing to put her own life on hold to do for others. You say you love each other's company but when you get married she has to fit in your family as a mother figure and everyone needs to feel free to enjoy each other's company. How can she do that when she is resentful and jealous of your youngest son who needs the most help? And how can he trust and love her when he feels she's competing for your affections.
These two sentences really bother me the most: "She feels like I pay more attention to my youngest son's feelings than I do hers. She has even said she feels second in my heart to him." Don't let her whining confuse you. She should be second place in your heart at this point; actually she should be fourth in your heart, right after each son. An unselfish woman would know that and would work to earn first place in your heart. A person doesn't move into first place just because they want to be there, nor is first place a gift that's just handed to a person. Placement is earned out of dignity, respect and honor and usually a lot of work. If it didn't then first place would have much importance.
Love has to go deeper than attraction and feelings. It has to withstand the daily trials of life and the occasional disaster. True love holds on to each other and digs roots deeper during hard times, working things out. Love never demands, nor does it allow a person to wine, or wallow in self-pity to get their own way. True love is mature, understanding, compassionate and giving. It's lifting up and encouraging the one they love and putting their desires before your own, in spite of your feelings. 1Corinthians 13:4-8 Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. Love never fails.
Since you feel she's a great lady and I don't know anymore about her than what you wrote. Test you feelings by looking at her objectively; evaluate her while putting your feelings aside to see if you feelings match up with what she really is. List the reasons why you think she's great, what are her good qualities then list what you don't like. Establish how stable she is in her life and how acceptable she is to change. A home with three boys is will be a lot of change for her to go through, when you marry. You don't need someone who will bail out on you because they're tired of cooking, cleaning or doing laundry. Is she stubborn or tender hearted? What assets does she bring to the whole family? Does her good qualities out weigh her insecurities? Is she mature and sensible in all she does? You don't need another child, nor do you need anymore stress in your life. By now you can probably think of more questions. Be thorough in you lists so you can make a fair evaluation. These are things that you need to pray about then God will help you work things out to benefit everyone. He has all the right answers but sometimes we have trouble hearing them so seek his guidance and be patient.
You write your relationship is not hindered due to your son not wanting you to be together. It really has been but you're not aware of it. You and your sons are a package deal and any woman you intend to marry must be mature enough to understand that she absolutely can never come between you and your boys. It's not a contest as to who you love the most. The right woman's objective should be to add fullness to you and your family or her love for you is not real, it's infatuation. Love is about wishing the other person to be well and happy all the time even if you have to sacrifice. A great marriage has sacrifices from both parties. Anything else comes from a spirit of selfishness which causes division. If she doesn't care about the same things you care about what do you have in common; especially when it's something as important as the welfare of your child?
You can't afford to go through another cycle of hurt and pain, and neither can your boys. Have you talked in depth to your son to get all the information about his feelings on this whole situation? Have you explained to him how you feel? Children are smart and compassionate when you open up to them. Your children need that closeness from you at this time. Have you tried talking as a family about the future with your lady present? Your son might respond better if he could ask her questions. If you're not ready to talk about the future of marriage then start with plans for next week or next month. Children want to feel included especially when all they have to depend on is one parent and you're not always with them. It's important to make them feel secure even when you're out on a date. Many times when questions are left unanswered in a person's mind it creates doubt, fear and insecurity. You should explain to everyone that you love each person differently and that each one has security in your love. Most families don't talk to each other enough which allows a lot of wrong thinking and misunderstandings.
Draw close to Jesus through worship and learning what's in God's word so the Holy Spirit can guide you. As the head of your household set a time aside so God can bless you and your boys together through Bible study. Just start in the New Testament and read a little to them several times a week. They will get such healing from the Holy Spirit as God's word moves into their minds. If you don't have any Christian music then get some. Music can soften the heart and bring peace to the mind. Maybe you can get your lady to participate in your family Bible time.
If you don't have a good church, please find one. In the next few days I will be publishing an article on how to choose a good church.
I would be very cautious if you choose to move forward in this relationship, give it a lot of thought and prayer. Give yourself plenty of time before making such an important decision. God loves you and his desires are the same as yours, that you have a happy loving home where your children will be raised to be strong healthy men and serve the Lord for all eternity. Start by taking your lady to church with your boys. If she isn't interested in your Christian lifestyle and the blessings that God has for your future then she's not the right woman for you. Then you'll need to seek God about that special one he has for you.
Psalms 37:4 Delight yourself in the Lord and he will give you the desires of your heart.